Lease or Buy Your Next Car? Here Is How to Do the Math

Lease or Buy Your Next Car? Here Is How to Do the Math
Key takeaways
  • Compare total cost over the same number of years
  • Leases suit predictable, moderate mileage
  • Buying usually wins if you keep cars six years or more
  • Convert the money factor to an interest rate by multiplying by 2,400

Leasing and buying can both be good deals. The right choice depends on how much you drive, how long you keep your cars and how you prefer to spend your money.

How a lease works

You pay for the car’s expected drop in value during the lease, plus a finance charge (the money factor) and fees. At the end, you return the car or buy it at a pre-set price.

  • Lower monthly payments than a loan on the same car
  • A new car every two to four years, usually under warranty
  • Mileage limits, often 10,000 to 15,000 miles a year
  • Charges for extra miles and excess wear

How buying works

You pay the full price with cash or a loan. When the loan is paid off, there is no payment at all, and the car is yours to keep or sell.

  • You build equity
  • No mileage limits or wear charges
  • Higher payments while the loan is active
  • Repair costs once the warranty ends

A simple way to compare

Pick a time period, for example six years. Then add up:

Two 3-year leasesOne 6-year loan
Money due at signingPaid twiceDown payment once
Monthly payments72 payments72 payments
FeesAcquisition and disposition fees, twiceLoan fees, if any
What you own at the endNothingThe car, minus its resale value

Subtract the car’s expected resale value from the loan total. The option with the lower final number costs less on paper.

Car keys on a table
A lease means handing back the keys every few years.

Leasing may suit you if

  • You drive a predictable, moderate number of miles
  • You like having the latest safety features
  • You prefer a lower payment and do not mind always having one

Buying may suit you if

  • You drive a lot each year
  • You keep cars for six years or longer
  • You want to be payment-free eventually

Lease tips

  • Negotiate the price of the car (capitalized cost) exactly as you would when buying.
  • Ask for the money factor and multiply it by 2,400 to see the equivalent interest rate.
  • Avoid a large down payment on a lease. If the car is totaled early, you may not get it back.

Keep reading: How to negotiate a new car price.